Bob From Brockley – Red Rosa v. Red-Pink Nadine

Bob From Brockley doesn’t like nationalism and dislikes the vicarious nationalism of faux anti-imperialists even more. On a recent demand that the EU “acknowledge the right of the Palestinian people to self-determination and, by so doing, recognise, Hamas as a legitimate voice for the Palestinian people’s aspirations for national liberation”:

“What’s wrong with the demand? As Transpontine said in a recent comment here,

Can we develop a kind of solidarity with civilians who happen to be Palestian (rather than ‘the Palestinian People’) that recognises and opposes their suffering at the hands of war machines without all the baggage of making them into a unique case?

To repeat something I’ve said before, those who talk most of The People are those who care least for real people, including real Palestinians. Or, as Rosa Luxemburg said,

the famous ‘right of self-determination of nations’ is nothing but hollow, bourgeois phraseology and humbug… [When it has been achieved,] it was really not the “people” who engaged in these reactionary policies, but only the bourgeois and petit bourgeois classes, who – in sharpest opposition to their own proletarian masses – perverted the ‘national right of self-determination’ into an instrument of their counter-revolutionary class policies. But – and here we come to the very heart of the question – it is in this that the utopian, petit bourgeois character of this nationalistic slogan resides: that in the midst of the crude realities of class society, especially when class antagonisms are sharpened to the uttermost, it is simply converted into a means of bourgeois class rule.

One of the few things worse than nationalism, in my view, is what Maurice Brinton of Solidarity called “vicarious” nationalism: the easy, exoticised celebration of the nationalisms of distant national elites, however reactionary, in lieu of the harder work of genuine solidarity with the common folk of those places.”

Read it all.


2 thoughts on “Bob From Brockley – Red Rosa v. Red-Pink Nadine

  1. Mira Vogel Post author

    I think Bob’s “back to scripture” approach to coping with aggression from faux anti-imperialists has a lot of cred.

    Sometimes I wish somebody that knowledgeable would start a reading group. He sounds busy though…


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s